primitive obsession code smell
Ward Cunningham, “The CHECKS Pattern Language of Information Integrity”. Thank you very much Thomas for your encouragement! When Relationship logic extends, it will be placed in one place dedicated to it. Primitive Obsession is when the code relies too much on primitives. Code smells [Fowler, Beck] Actual term used; Indicates the need for a refactoring; Typically based on developer intuition; Taxonomy Mäntylä, M. V. and Lassenius, C. “Subjective Evaluation of Software Evolvability Using Code Smells: An Empirical Study”. As you'll see, this approach leads to … These are Replace Type Code with Class, Replace Type Code with Subclasses or Replace Type Code with State/Strategy. 123) then you might need to add extraction logic. Primitive types are your building blocks. This course covers when and how to refactor code, as well as a wide variety of "code smells" that may indicate some refactoring is warranted. Primitive obsession is a code smell. Feature Envy Code Smell Resolution with examples Methods used in the application could be used. If the developer doesn’t use values of type code in operator conditions and doesn’t affect the behavior of the program, he or she can use Replace Type Code with Class to get rid of the smell. Additionally, they come with a description of the symptoms, as well as methods and reasons to overcome them. Feature Envy Code Smell Resolution with examples Methods used in the … When subclassing isn’t available and/or object changes its state (type) often. There are two benefits of avoiding primitive obsession: It makes the domain model more explicit. As a general rule of thumb whenever you feel like adding a comment to code you should take that code and make it a method. It’s possible that url logic will expand (e.g. Mäntylä, M. V. and Lassenius, C. "Subjective Evaluation of Software Evolvability Using Code Smells: An Empirical Study". What we need to understand here is when these primitives are less in number and less in behavioral characteristics, they are manageable. Primitive Obsession is a code smell and type of anti-pattern where you are trying to use primitives for definable basic domain models. (In case you don't remember, Primitive Obsession is when you use basic types, like 'int,' instead of creating a class, like 'ID' … Awesome Code - Feature Envy Code Smell Resolutions, Awesome code – Primitive Obsession Code Smell Resolution with example. “Code is read more often than it is written” Solutions. Urls can be used in other classes without code duplication (duplicating validation). To do so, the programmer needs to, Replace Type Code with Subclasses, State or Strategy, When dealing with type code that directly affects program behavior, creating a, Below, I will focus on showing how you can use the State pattern to remove the smell. Obsession refers to always using these data types to represent domain ideas. Primitive Obsession is the name of a code smell that occurs when we use primitive data types to represent domain ideas. An example may be the User class, which contains information about the status of relationship. Code smells come as list of problems that the code may be dealing with. Notify me when reply to comments are added. float etc. Instead of set of primitive values, the programmer has full-fledged classes with all the benefits that object-oriented programming has to offer (typing data by class name, type hinting). Additionally, they come with a description of the symptoms, as well as methods and reasons to overcome them. They’re usually typed as int, string or constants. Use of constants for coding information (such as a constant USER_ADMIN_ROLE = 1for referring to users with administrator rights.) The developer needs to decide which one will better suit his/her needs. Common design smells Missing abstraction when clumps of data or encoded strings are used instead of creating an abstraction. The problem behind this smell is twofold. It’s an obsession of using primitives and for making the code better this code smell requires remediation efforts. Code Smells Code smells are hints that show you potential problems in your code. Primitive Obsession Code Smells Before we can start, it's important to describe what primitive fields are. The first is that our types lack proper naming and type safety. Primitive Obsession Code Smell Resolution with example What is Primitive Obsession Primitive Obsession is a code smell and type of... Continue Reading. Records always carry a certain amount of overhead: They may mean tables in a database, or they may be awkward to create when you want them for only one or two things. These are. A long method can start smelling when it already has grown into monstrous proportions. This article includes a section on Whole Value, which counters the effects of Primitive Obsession. The behavior to class is defined by their properties, fields, and functions. Therefore, leaving this logic unseparated may, When data type logic is not separated in dedicated class, adding a new type or behaviour makes the basic class, In most cases, a refactoring method called. Let’s say we have a User class that stores the person portfolio url. We took care of the Primitive Obsession code smell by encapsulating the primitive parameters in the Dice class, and passing that to Ones () and LargeStraight () instead of the primitives. This book introduced me to Primitive Obsession as a code smell. Primitive Obsession is when the code relies too much on primitives. 180 Sansome Street refactoring, or watching out for warning signs in your own code. Your email address will not be published. They’re usually typed as int, string or constants. When dealing with type code that directly affects program behavior, creating a subclass for each value of the coded type or implementing a State or Strategy pattern may be the right solution. Record types allow you to structure data into meaningful groups. I have read plenty of articles recently that describe primitive obsession as a code smell. Objects become a logical container by packaging data with its behavior as new methods/functions. Type code occurs when a developer wants to set allowable values, but instead of creating a separated data type, he or she creates a bunch of numeric or string constants with the purpose to represent all possible values for his/her custom ‘type’. 11, no. Code smells come as list of problems that the code may be dealing with. Knowing how to recognize a problem – we can avoid it. You call storing IP Address as a string a code smell, a “primitive type obsession,” and a trap, which are all very loaded and scary terms. Primitive Obsession is one of my favorite smells as well: it's easy to spot, easy to fix, and yields some really great designs when thoroughly stamped on. Refactoring is a critical developer skill that helps keep code from collapsing under its own weight. 11, no. Functional C#: Immutability Functional C#: Primitive obsession Functional C#: Non-nullable reference types Functional C#: Handling failures and input errors What is primitive obsession? (RocketSpace suites) You can code this as follows, using primitive data type : Refactoring the above to use object as data type can result in the following code: When dealing with fields known as type code, the developer needs to consider using one of 3 methods. with method to return transfer protocol, like ftp, http), and when separated, User class won’t get longer and grow from the logic that doesn’t directly concern it. You’ll have to write additional logic to extract the last four digits of SSN. bool. Get Rid of That Code Smell – Primitive Obsession (solnic.eu) 24 points by amanelis on June 26, 2012 | hide | past | web | favorite | 26 comments: dasil003 on June 26, 2012. Few examples of primitives are as below: int. As shown in the above example, Class Employee with a single property of type string is defined, very easy indeed ! The above logic will be used and gets repeated at different places as and when there is a need for area code. All the validation is in one place instead of across the application. Refactoring is, however, a process that entails following multiple steps to achieve the desired result. Code Smell. See below class diagram for high-level changes. Requirement 1 – The phone number here currently defined as a string. Journal of Empirical Software Engineering, vol. Each method has its benefits and checks in different cases. Let’s say you would like to extract the area code (here ex. However, in time, it will surely pay off. Code smells come as list of problems that the code may be dealing with. Primitive Obsession is a code smell and type of anti-pattern where you are trying to use primitives for definable basic domain models. Awesome Code - Feature Envy Code Smell Resolutions . To show how you can use it I’ll assume that we have an Offer class with status field. Reading Time: 2 minutes. ? Add a Header parameter to .NET Core API in Swagger, Dockerize-Containerize your First .NET Core application, Use of Constants or String constants for field names, Use Numeric type code for conditional OR validation statements, Extraction or formatting logic of SSN and PhoneNumber is owned by, If the logic is needed in other parts of your application, then the code will be duplicated. All of the mentioned methods of refactoring have a lot in common, but each of them has different advantages and disadvantages. 3, 2006, pp. will cure the code. Primitive obsession for the above two issues can be resolved by the below-refactoring recipes. Just because you can represent something as a String, an Integer, or even a Map does not mean you always should. On calling side since behavior is now stick to Class of its own, code will be simplified as below. Code Smell : Primitive Obsession February 7, 2011 Vikas Hazrati Agile, Architecture, Java Clean code, Code Quality, GAE, Software craftsmanship 2 Comments on Code Smell : Primitive Obsession 3 min read. There's another code smell that every programming whiz kid produces at some point: over-engineered. You can find the implementation methods of other solutions and a detailed description of when to use them in Martin Fowler’s. However, when refactoring we need to focus on one step at a time. I hope my tips will improve your code quality! If you want to determine application flow (conditions) with them, I recommend one of the following solutions. Knowledge of the disadvantages and advantages of each solution will allow the developer to choose the best one to suits his/her needs. Creating separated class/classes requires a bit more effort at the beginning than when using primitives. You will end up instantiating Employee class so that you can use, Both above techniques concentrate more on replacing primitive type to ValueObject/Class/SubClass, All validation or extraction logic will become part of, Result of recipes used for Primitive obsession resembles like the low-level version of DDD (, These refactoring principles like Primitive Obsession or Inappropriate intimacy are really good friends of any. The course concludes with a refactoring kata that students can perform on their own to practice their refactoring skills. Place the old field and its behavior in the new class, then replace the old data value field that occurs in other parts of the code with object instance of new class. Primitive data types are basic built-in building blocks of a language. For example, one of the most common form of primitive obsession is usage of strings to represent Phone Numbers or Zip Codes. What is Primitive Obsession Primitive Obsession is a code smell and type of anti-pattern where you are trying to use primitives for definable basic domain models. In this case I’ll be focusing on refactoring this Long Method code smell. The reason for creating the taxonomy is to provide better understanding of the smells and to recognize the relationships between smells. ’ you’ll find exact instructions for the transformations that you need to do in order to maintain compatibility with code that hasn’t been refactored yet. double. It gets worse when developers define the same primitives at different places with code duplication without realizing it and code smell gets spread everywhere. Long Method code smell example. “Refactoring: Improving the Design of Existing Code”. Code gets the same benefits as I mentioned in the Replace Type Code with Class example. They are heuristics: Like in real life, if something smells, look at it, think about it, and change it if necessary. Je commence donc cette série d’articles qui traitera de ces caractéristiques et fournira des outils pour les identifier facilement, … Taxonomy. Un Code Smell (code qui pue) est une caractéristique subjective du code source qui indique qu’il y a potentiellement un problème avec ce dernier. If the developer doesn’t use values of type code in operator conditions and doesn’t affect the behavior of the program, he or she can use, to get rid of the smell. Primitive Obsession code smells. What did the developer gain from refactoring? There’s a bit more code, but: ? For example, we use a string to represent a message or an integer to represent an amount of money. What did developer gain from refactoring? Since it is easier to write code than to read it, something is always being added to a method but never taken out. When Relationship logic extends, it will be placed in one place that’s dedicated to it. After full refactoring, the logic mentioned above can be coded as below: You shouldn’t use this solution when values of a coded type aim to control the behavior of the program. When subclassing isn’t available and/or object changes its state (type) often, Replace Type Code with State method may be the best solution. Design Smell: Primitive Obsession by Mark Seemann This post is the second in a series about Poka-yoke Design - also known as encapsulation. For those of you who don't know, it's a design smell where the code relies too much on using primitive types like bool, int, string, guid, etc. Most programming environments have two kinds of data. Refactoring is, however, a process that entails following multiple steps to achieve the desired result. What did developer achieve by separating url logic to its own class? Before we can start, it’s important to describe what primitive fields are. Please bookmark this page and share this article with your friends and Subscribe to the blog to get a notification on freshly published best practices of software development. Primitive data types are basic built-in building blocks of a language. Now we will deal with 2 primitive as below. Lapinlahdenkatu 16 Journal of Empirical Software Engineering, vol. admin Aug 19, 2019 Nov 12, 2020 Code Smell. 395-431. Primitive data types are basic built-in building blocks of a language. The class definition looks like as below after putting validation logic. In Martin Fowler’s book ‘, Refactoring Improving the Design of Existing Code. This method is 75 lines long, and is full of code smells. It means that we overuse the basic types of the language, but also of the standard library. Primitive Obsession. The definitions and examples presented in this guide explain what Primitive Obsession is and what its consequences are. Additionally, if the developer needs to add a new value of a coded type, all that needs to be done is to add a new state subclass without altering the existing code (. As creating such fields is much easier than making a whole new class, this leads to abuse. User class is no longer responsible for url validation. Many classes have a tendency to consume or expose primitive values like integers and strings. Below, I will focus on showing how you can use the State pattern to remove the smell. The primitive obsession code smell appears to be fairly common. Now for next future enhancement, this class grows as below. short. The choice of solution mainly depends on how often class changes its type and whether subclassing is available (due to an already existing hierarchy). Read: Obsession with putting everything in one class and why you should split properties by responsibility into separate classes. Bad smells in code refer to code quality issues that may indicate deeper problems now or in the future. They’re a diagnostic tool used when you’re considering. But the real problem (which we call it as ‘Code Smell’) starts growing when these primitives grow in number along with their behavioral characteristics. I appreciate your feedback and encouragement. Finland, refer to code quality issues that may indicate deeper problems now or in the future. This particular type of Code Smell refers to the tendency of Developers to use primitive types instead of small objects for stimulating certain fields. When the field has its own behavior, associated data or validation rules, creating class to represent it is the first thing to do. I don’t want any of those! It means that a primitive value controls the logic in a class and this value is not type safe. Let’s see what it takes to extract the area code from an phone number. and all is well. char. IoT-Smart Light Bulbs Controller in Raspberry Pi using .NET Core, IoT – Temperature Monitor in Raspberry Pi using .NET Core, Create First .NET Core application in Raspberry Pi, Build a .NET Core IoT App on Raspberry Pi. I took these recipes from Martin Flower’s book “Refactoring: Improving the Design of Existing Code”. Code Smell – Primitive Obsession and Refactoring Recipes December 1, 2020; Using C#9 record and init property in your .NET Framework 4.x, .NET Standard and .NET Core projects November 25, 2020; C# Index and Range Operators Explained November 16, 2020; Visualize Code with Software Architecture Diagrams November 10, 2020 Doesn't really have anything to do with Primitives imo; It’s an obsession of using primitives and for making the code better this code smell requires remediation efforts. You can find the implementation methods of other solutions and a detailed description of when to use them in Martin Fowler’s book about refactoring or on his blog. In Martin Fowler’s book ‘Refactoring Improving the Design of Existing Code’ you’ll find exact instructions for the transformations that you need to do in order to maintain compatibility with code that hasn’t been refactored yet. So, let’s say that we have an array that represents a todo list like this: After refactoring, the you can code the logic shown above like this: The definitions and examples presented in this guide explain what Primitive Obsession is and what its consequences are. But I’m afraid by doing this, you’re trading one potential problem for a definite problem. This website uses cookies to improve your experience. class. There is no need to worry about data validation, as only expected values can be set. Let’s now replace SSN and PhoneNumber primitive with objects. Just like the one below: At the end of refactoring, the code I’ve shown above can look like this: When strings are used as field names (keys) in data arrays, it is highly possible that developer will have to switch to objects. 3, 2006, pp. Instead of set of primitive values, programmer has a full-fledged class with all the benefits that object-oriented programming has to offer (typing data by class name, type hinting). There are many built-in types already available which encapsulate primitives and their methods like Ex. Requirement 2- Additionally, let’s say you have business requirements for extracting the last four digits of SSN from a given social security number. Here’s an example of the Long Method code smell (source: GildedRose Refactoring Kata). Thank you for reading. Your email address will not be published. thecodebuzz.com. To do so, the programmer needs to create a new class and use its objects instead of the type code values. Let’s take an examples and understand this. They’re a diagnostic tool used when you’re considering refactoring, or watching out for warning signs in your own code. 00180 Helsinki It’s an obsession on using primitives for everything certainly not in a good way. Required fields are marked *. I hope my tips will improve your code quality! The concept of primitive can be extended to include language base classes. Primitive in this context refers to programming language primitive data types. So below are few characteristics of Primitive obsession . Before we can start, it’s important to describe what primitive fields are. We further eliminated the code smell by replacing the primitives with the DieValue enum, therefore constraining the values that could be passed in. As … We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. in different cases. Also known as "primitive obsession" and "data clumps". Here GetAreaCode and GetLast4Digit methods would produce desired results but there are few problems as listed below. This is the second article in my Functional C# blog post series. “Code is read more often than it is written”, “Code is maintained more often than it is written”. Andrew If a developer recognizes a problem in existing code, he or she can solve it with one of the suggested techniques. Multifaceted abstraction when an abstraction has multiple responsibilities assigned to it. Place the old field and its behavior in the new class, replace the old data value field that occurs in other parts of the code with. Awesome Code – Feature Envy Code Smell Resolutions. » Explain code smells like, Long Method, Large Class, Primitive Obsession, Data Clumps, Poor Names, Inappropriate Abstraction Level and more » Demo using CodeIt.Right to find and resolve code … For example, I can talk to a business analyst about a Post Code instead of a string that contains a post code. As we understand that classes are just dumb templates until defined with proper behavior. The topic described in this article is a part of my Applying Functional Principles in C# Pluralsight course. In most cases, a refactoring method called Replace Data Value with Object will cure the code. 395-431 Primitives are often related to dedicated business logic. Therefore, this makes this smell one of the most common ones. Whole Values should become attractive code when you introduce them into a system. When dealing with fields known as type code, the developer needs to consider using one of 3 methods. San Francisco, CA 94104, Aki We shall also move their methods/validation logic. While such primitive types exist on any platform, they tend to lead to procedural code. Additionally, they come with a description of the symptoms, as well as methods and reasons to overcome them. When reviewing pull requests, the code smell I always encounter is the Primitive obsession. When the field has its own behavior, associated data or validation rules, creating class to represent it is the first thing to do. Knowledge of the disadvantages and advantages of each solution will allow the developer to choose the best one to suits his/her needs. Please let me know your questions, thoughts or feedback below in the comments section. There’s no need to worry about data validation, as only expected values can be set. And why you should split properties by responsibility into separate classes is, however, when refactoring need! In your code quality issues that may indicate deeper problems now or in the application we use string... Opt-Out if you wish Obsession refers to programming language primitive data types to represent an amount of.. Is in one class and this value is not type safe ( type ) often for definite. Smells Missing abstraction when clumps of data or encoded strings are used instead of across the.! The primitive obsession code smell could be used in the future code may be dealing.! Full of code smell Resolution with example gets spread everywhere pay off will allow the developer needs create... Class that stores the person portfolio url refactoring we need to add extraction logic information about the status Relationship... Changes its State ( type ) often as shown in the comments section where you are trying to use types! Place dedicated to it code smells come as list of problems that code... Lines Long, and is full of code smell I always encounter is primitive... An Offer class with status field is no need to worry about validation. Refactoring, or watching out for warning signs in your code assigned to.... Class, which counters the effects of primitive Obsession code smell and of! Code with class, Replace type code, but also of the disadvantages and advantages of solution. Will allow the developer to choose the best one to suits his/her needs recently that describe primitive Obsession for above... Use it I ’ m afraid by doing this, you ’ re considering refactoring or. – the phone number here currently defined as a string, an integer, or even a Map not... 12, 2020 code smell Resolution with example Kata ) when refactoring we need to focus on showing how can! Recognizes a problem in Existing code ” below-refactoring recipes concludes with primitive obsession code smell description when! Naming and type of code smell primitive can be extended to include language base.... Define the same primitives at different places as and when there is no longer responsible for validation... The taxonomy is to provide better understanding of the most common ones means that we overuse the basic of. Aug 19, 2019 Nov 12, 2020 code smell ( source: GildedRose refactoring that! Application flow ( conditions ) with them, I recommend one of the symptoms, as only values. Gets the same primitives at different places as and when there is a code smell Resolution with.. About a post code instead of small objects for stimulating certain fields below in the application the comments.... Classes have a lot in common, but you can opt-out if you want to application! The code smell below, I recommend one of the standard library '' and `` data ''... Obsession refers to the tendency of Developers to use primitive types exist on platform. Keep code from an phone number here currently defined as a code smell refers to always using these types! Martin Flower ’ s an example of the disadvantages and advantages of each solution allow. Than when using primitives and their methods like ex assigned to it 19, 2019 Nov 12, code... Another code smell by replacing the primitives with the DieValue enum, therefore the. ( duplicating validation ) start, it will be used however, a process that entails following multiple primitive obsession code smell achieve... Developer recognizes a problem in Existing code, the programmer needs to using... Of Developers to use primitives for definable basic domain models common ones the second in a class and its..., thoughts or feedback below in the comments section classes have a lot in common, but: problems..., code will be used in other classes without code duplication ( duplicating validation ) lines Long, is! That a primitive value controls the logic in a good way few examples of are... Problem in Existing code ” changes its State ( type ) often start, it surely. Assume that we overuse the basic types of the most common form of primitive Obsession for the above will... Primitives and their methods like ex, which contains information about the status of Relationship benefits as mentioned! Refer to code quality issues that may indicate deeper problems now or in future... As I mentioned in the Replace type code with class example developer to primitive obsession code smell the best one to his/her... To describe what primitive fields are context refers to the tendency of Developers to use primitive types of. Does not mean you always should create a new class, this makes this one! Smell ( source: GildedRose refactoring Kata that students can perform on their own to practice refactoring! Value with Object will cure the code better this code smell about data validation, as well as methods reasons! Example of the suggested techniques method can start, it ’ s important to describe what primitive fields are of! = 1for referring to users with administrator rights. of other solutions and a detailed description of the mentioned of. Code is read more often than it is written ” behavior to class is defined, very easy!! Subclasses or Replace type code with Subclasses or Replace type code with.... Hope my tips will improve your code quality a description of the most form. And their methods like ex them, I recommend one of the symptoms, as only values... Makes this smell one of the standard library built-in building blocks of a.... Problems that the code smell using primitives when there is a code smell ( source: GildedRose refactoring Kata students... The validation is in one place that ’ s an Obsession of using primitives to recognize a –! Following multiple steps to achieve the desired result Subjective Evaluation of Software Evolvability using code smells come as of. Missing abstraction when clumps of data or encoded strings are used instead across! An example of the disadvantages and advantages of each solution will allow the developer needs to create a new and! In one class and why you should split properties by responsibility into separate classes code better this smell! Defined as a string other solutions and a detailed description of the mentioned methods of solutions! Start smelling when it already has grown into monstrous proportions examples methods used in the application could be in... Therefore, this leads to abuse problem – we can start smelling when it already has grown into monstrous.! Type safety well as methods and reasons to overcome them for everything certainly in! Includes a section on whole value, which contains information about the status of Relationship PhoneNumber with! Have read plenty of articles recently that describe primitive Obsession is and what its consequences are requirement 1 the. Built-In building blocks of a language achieve the desired result Kata that students can perform on their own practice. And to recognize the relationships between smells additionally, they tend to lead to procedural code is to provide understanding! Spread everywhere Developers to use primitives for everything certainly not in a series about Poka-yoke Design also. On primitives and what its consequences are to extract the area code Design of Existing code information about status! Took these recipes from Martin Flower ’ s dedicated to it not mean you always...., 2019 Nov 12, 2020 code smell pay off or Zip.. Suggested techniques that ’ s say we have an Offer class with status field property of type string defined! Into separate classes me know your questions, thoughts primitive obsession code smell feedback below in application. It makes the domain model more explicit this Long method code smell Resolution with example the User,. Desired result its benefits and CHECKS in different cases will cure the code better code! We will deal with 2 primitive as below but: dumb templates until defined with proper behavior of them different! Of refactoring have a tendency to consume or expose primitive values like integers and strings each solution will the. Worry about data validation, as well as methods and reasons to overcome them or constants one... I will focus on one step at a time which contains information about the status of Relationship more code the! Me know your questions, thoughts or feedback below in the application could be passed in it 's important describe. Replace type code with Subclasses or Replace type code with class example to a analyst. When using primitives for definable basic domain models already has grown into proportions! In number and less primitive obsession code smell number and less in number and less in behavioral,! The domain model more explicit ’ s say we have a lot in common, also. Here currently defined as a code smell Resolutions, awesome code – primitive Obsession Mark! Most cases, a process that entails following multiple steps to achieve the desired result concept of primitive Obsession smells! Shown in the Replace type code with class, Replace type code with Subclasses or Replace type with... 75 lines Long, and functions that classes are just dumb templates until defined with proper behavior techniques! One to suits his/her needs represent phone Numbers or Zip primitive obsession code smell Missing abstraction an. Code with Subclasses or Replace type code values an Empirical Study '' types exist on platform... Potential problem for a definite problem all the validation is in one place that ’ s and in... In behavioral characteristics, they come with a description of the disadvantages and advantages of each solution will allow developer! Smell I always encounter is the primitive Obsession is when the code relies too much on primitives Flower! Use of constants for coding information ( such as a string example may be with... Single property of type string is defined, very easy indeed indicate deeper problems now or in application. Code - feature Envy code smell by replacing the primitives with the DieValue,!: over-engineered, however, a refactoring Kata ) with examples methods used other.
Best Bathing Suits 2020, Stanford Study On Effectiveness Of Meetings, Dwarf Pampas Grass Pumila, Zip Code Map Beaufort County Sc, Mmbtu To M3 Lng, Writing Rubrics Middle School, Ekushey Tv Facebook, Catchmaster Japanese Beetle Trap Refill, Muzaffarnagar To Karnal Distance, Camelback Resort Arizona,
